When one hotel chain says there’s a 2,000 point bonus per stay, it doesn’t mean much, but when another does, it’s almost worth going out of your way to lock in. Why? Hotel points from each loyalty program are worth vastly different amounts, no matter what they try to tell you!

Don’t fret, it’s simple. You just need to establish a baseline, and then all the marketing and talk will make more sense.

It’s because 2,000 hotel points with one chain can be vastly more valuable than 2,000 with another, and even 90,000 points with one leading hotel loyalty program may be less valuable than 30,000 with another! It sounds crazy, but it’s all relatively simple.

Here’s how to understand and navigate hotel points, for good and for all!

Misconceptions With Hotel Loyalty Points

One of the larger misconceptions with points is that they’re all basically same, so let’s take a second to break down why you might want to look more closely at the hotel points offers you see flashed into your loyalty accounts, and which points from brands like Hilton, Hyatt, Marriott, IHG and Accor are best to collect.

Basically, hotel points are like money. Not every currency starts at the same value.

Here’s a perfect example to start: Hyatt recently offered 3,000 bonus points per stay at select hotels, while Hilton offered 2,000. These may sound like similar amounts, but they’re not at all.

One Hyatt point is at least 3X more valuable than one Hilton Honors Point, and therefore the Hyatt promotion is even more valuable on the surface than the points difference would suggest. In fact, even if it was Hilton offering 3,000 and Hyatt offering 2,000 the Hyatt promotion would still be more valuable, by a long shot!

That doesn’t mean one loyalty program is better than another. It just means they do things different when it comes to points. Just like countries do money differently. A lot doesn’t always mean a lot.

Why are Hyatt Points worth more than Hilton Points, on a per point basis you say? Because the highest end Hyatt hotels you can book top out at 40,000 points per night.

Almost all the standard five star hotels you’d want to experience, like the Park Hyatt Tokyo, or Andaz New York will be just 30,000, 25,000 World of Hyatt Points or fewer. Make 10 stays with the 3,000 bonus points, you’d have enough for one night, maybe even with a few left over.

Hilton on the other hand, tops out at an astronomical 95,000-120,000 points per night, and at 2,000 points per stay, you’d need 46 nights or more to earn the points needed by the bonus alone. Hilton has other great ways to earn points, like credit cards which offer over 150,000 points as a welcome bonus, but it’s a great illustration of the basic differences.

Just like $1 isn’t the same as £1, one point with one chain doesn’t start out with the same value as others.

Is it the same with other hotel chains, like IHG, Marriott, Accor and others? You bet! Here’s a little breakdown of how each program’s points are valued…

The Overall Picture Isn’t As Simple

In this example, you’d think Hyatt is obviously the loyalty program for you. It might be, but it’s just not quite that simple, unless you happen to earn most of your points via Chase Ultimate Rewards Cards, which can be turned into Hyatt Points 1:1.

For actual stays, its best to think of points earned like a cash rebate dished out in points – – and most programs offer a similar level of rebate, between 4-8% back on each stay.

That’s why on the face of things, it may seem like Hilton is more generous by offering 10X points per dollar spent, than most which offer just 5X, but since they start out at different values, it all kinda evens out.

If the way you earn free nights, points and perks is from hotel stays rather than credit card spending, all the loyalty programs are actually really close in the rebate you get as a reward.

If you have the time, I highly suggest reading this comparative guide which explains that much further.

Each hotel chain offers varying level of rebate for general members, and for members who earn elite status and jump up the tiers of loyalty. Statistically, Wyndham, Hyatt and Marriott offer the best rebate, with each above 7%, whereas IHG and Hilton are more around 6%. For elite members, things change a bit.

Making Your Hotel Point Calculations

Now, onto calculating the respective values of each points program. This is how you figure out what kind of value you should get for your points with each program, and helps to explain why fewer points from one, can be more valuable than more points from another.

For simplicity sake, you can work with the assumption that your points from various hotel programs are worth…

  • Marriott Bonvoy Points are worth around 0.6 cents per point.
  • IHG Rewards Club Points are worth around 0.5 cents per point.
  • Hilton Honors Points are worth around 0.4 cents per point.
  • World Of Hyatt Points are worth around 1.5 cents per point.
  • Radisson Rewards are worth around 0.4 cents per point.

These points valuations may be off by 0.1 or similar margins in some instances, but that all depends how you use the points, and see the trajectory of loyalty programs. Don’t worry about it. Just use the figures as a baseline of value, and try to do better with your stash of points.

Think: 100,000 points at .5 cents per point should be worth $500.

Knowing the minimum value you should be deriving from your points in each loyalty currency can help you to understand better what things like credit card bonuses are actually worth, rather than just whether they sound “big” or not.

If a hotel bonus offer is worth going out of your way for, we’ll always give it a big shout in our credit card news section!

How To Calculate Value Of Hotel Points

If you’re unsure how to make sense of those calculations, let’s use the 150,000 point, or three free night Marriott Point Bonvoy Boundless Credit Card bonus as a guide.

To understand the minimum value you’d hope to extract from that bonus, you’d multiply the number of points by the point valuation they offer above, like (150,000 x 0.006), for a total of 600, which you can then stick a dollar ($) sign in front of.

For that bonus, you’d hope to extract at least $900 worth of hotel nights, upgrades, or other ways of using Marriott Bonvoy Points. How to figure that out? Check the price of the same night you hope to book using points, as if you’re going to use cash. If the paid cash rates add up to more than the value you tallied up your points, then you’re doing it right.

Back to the comparative value of different programs, It’s why something like a 60,000 point World Of Hyatt Credit Card offer might not sound nearly as exciting on the face, compared to 150,000 from Hilton, Marriott, IHG or others, but at (60,000 x 0.015 value, you’d expect $900 of value, which is a near identical return for signing up.

Hopefully, this will give you a clearer understanding of just “how good” or how “underwhelming” an offer might be, and explain why 60,000 points from one brand is as good as 150,000 from another – or better!

If you have the time, it’s really worth diving deeper into the rebates each hotel group brings on actual stays, since it can really paint a clearer picture of what you should be focusing on. The more you know!

Gilbert Ott

Gilbert Ott is an ever curious traveler and one of the world's leading travel experts. His adventures take him all over the globe, often spanning over 200,000 miles a year and his travel exploits are regularly...

Join the Conversation

6 Comments

  1. How do Accor points fit with this bunch? On the face of it they are pretty transparent within Accor when it comes to spending. You also get extra points depending on your status but was wondering how they compare with these usual suspects.

    Have to say also I just spent 8 nights at the sofitel in LA and have the new Diamond status and got a whole host of benefits beyond the ones listed for diamond. 1 movie per night / breakfast everyday (instead of the stated weekend only) and having booked the basic room I got a full suit upgrade with Hollywood sign view ( there are also ones that aren’t).

    Thanks

  2. Thanks Gilbert…. Accor is a good topic following on from your blog on bloggers integrity the other day. One other points site never ever talks about Accor – I guess they don’t sponsor them unlike the US trio of hyatt, Marriott and Hilton. Yet away from the US I find Accor pretty good since you have the full range with them. I do note that as of this year SLS and Delano for example in the US are bookable on the Accor website for the first time and with points. Never seen that mentioned on said points site 😉

  3. The sofitel you stayed at may have been generous during Covid.
    But if you look at the program it is a really a FOURTH class elite program compared to hyatt, marriott, hilton. I dont know why anyone would waste time with it. It is useless!!
    1. very difficult to get Diamond ($12000 spend)
    2. even with it breakfast only on weekends is PITIFUL (i dont like to hope for exceptions especially when breakfast for two can easily run $60 per day).
    3. Suite upgrades NOT included (again why hope for an exception when the other programs guarantee it most of the time)
    4.their points expire after 12months with no stays and no way to get extension except with a stay.

    My colleagues and I travel business 150+ days per year and would never consider Accor .

Leave a comment